This was our first trip to this neat little shop. We tried the coconut macaron, the strawberry cake, the sugar, cookie truffle, the chocolate cake shake, and the funfetti cake shake. All were delicious. If you like sweets, this is one of the best things that will ever happen to your life. My kids devoured the cake shakes. I tried both of them. They were delicious. I am not a macaron guy, but my wife said they were good. The strawberry cake had a delicious frosting, and it was very rich! My favorite thing was either the chocolate cake shake, or the sugar cookie truffle. They were both out of this world. Do not be fooled by the slump block building along the highway. The place is very clean and modern inside. The level of customer service is something you would only find in Mayberry. Even the other customers were super friendly. We definitely will be back every time we are in the Gila Valley.
Mary Ann Haws
-
March 25, 2022
We haven't had a treat we didn't like. The cake is flavourful, moist, and beautiful. We ordered 5 different cakes for our wedding and we constantly have friends & family bring up how delicious they were.
Macaroons are notoriously hard to make and Shelbycake has mastered it. The crisp and the chew comes together beautifully. They are tasty and toothsome.
I love following along on IG and I can't wait to see what Shelbycake comes up with next.
KB
-
March 13, 2023
UPDATE: Leaving a response basically denying everything we said about our experience with your company looks awful on a business and makes it look like your company can do no wrong. It’s not an argument. It’s my experience with your company. Take the feedback and criticism and improve for the future, don’t try to prove your customers wrong by replying with a comment. It’s unprofessional. Also after we put this review up we received phone calls/ voicemails asking us to take the review down because we had not told the truth about our experience (they basically said we were lying). I’m baffled.
Shelby Cake has delicious cake! We usually have an amazing experience, but we ordered our wedding cake here and I have to say I'm more than disappointed. When we ordered our cake we were told that it would be able to be transported without an issue and that it would stay in tact well. (We had placed an order for a 4 tiered cake.) We had the exact opposite experience. Our cake had to travel 4 hours to make it to our wedding. We asked for it to be separated into 4 different tiers so that we could insure that it would stay nice, but it was only separated into 2 separate pieces when we picked it up. The bottom two tiers were together and they brought out to the car WITHOUT BEING PUT IN A BOX! How can you expect a cake to travel 4 hours outside a box? You can't. When they placed the cake in the vehicle they bumped it against the seat and messed up some of the frosting, not to mention the top was cracked. The second tier was lopsided and falling over ( not from the drive , we received it that way!) And the bottom of the layers were lifting up. When I got a closer chance to look at the cake it looked poorly made and the frosting look liked it has been done in about 2 seconds. The cake was very expensive and not worth the money we paid for it. With it being a wedding cake we expected the best, but received the worst. The cake was delicious and our guests loved it, but it was lopsided in pictures and several of our guests noticed it, it was tacky. I DO NOT recommend ordering a wedding cake here, especially if it has to travel more than a few minutes!
Sandra Toller
-
May 19, 2022
My experience at Shelbycake was nothing less than the best!!! I’m not the type of person who chooses cake for a desert but her cake is A+! Not only that, but I LOVE how there are options for other kinds of deserts. I tried basically everything in the shop and Personally, my favorites were her ice cream bowls, Oreo truffles, and macaroons! Her ice cream bowls have cake folded into the ice cream and it just the perfect blend! If you are ever passing through, I highly suggest stopping in!
Kayla Shores
-
February 13, 2022
Great to work with made some delicious cakes and cupcakes very reasonably priced.Everything was ready for pickup when we arrived and enjoyed all the personal touches they added! Definitely will use again!!
This was our first trip to this neat little shop. We tried the coconut macaron, the strawberry cake, the sugar, cookie truffle, the chocolate cake shake, and the funfetti cake shake. All were delicious. If you like sweets, this is one of the best things that will ever happen to your life. My kids devoured the cake shakes. I tried both of them. They were delicious. I am not a macaron guy, but my wife said they were good. The strawberry cake had a delicious frosting, and it was very rich! My favorite thing was either the chocolate cake shake, or the sugar cookie truffle. They were both out of this world. Do not be fooled by the slump block building along the highway. The place is very clean and modern inside. The level of customer service is something you would only find in Mayberry. Even the other customers were super friendly. We definitely will be back every time we are in the Gila Valley.
We haven't had a treat we didn't like. The cake is flavourful, moist, and beautiful. We ordered 5 different cakes for our wedding and we constantly have friends & family bring up how delicious they were. Macaroons are notoriously hard to make and Shelbycake has mastered it. The crisp and the chew comes together beautifully. They are tasty and toothsome. I love following along on IG and I can't wait to see what Shelbycake comes up with next.
UPDATE: Leaving a response basically denying everything we said about our experience with your company looks awful on a business and makes it look like your company can do no wrong. It’s not an argument. It’s my experience with your company. Take the feedback and criticism and improve for the future, don’t try to prove your customers wrong by replying with a comment. It’s unprofessional. Also after we put this review up we received phone calls/ voicemails asking us to take the review down because we had not told the truth about our experience (they basically said we were lying). I’m baffled. Shelby Cake has delicious cake! We usually have an amazing experience, but we ordered our wedding cake here and I have to say I'm more than disappointed. When we ordered our cake we were told that it would be able to be transported without an issue and that it would stay in tact well. (We had placed an order for a 4 tiered cake.) We had the exact opposite experience. Our cake had to travel 4 hours to make it to our wedding. We asked for it to be separated into 4 different tiers so that we could insure that it would stay nice, but it was only separated into 2 separate pieces when we picked it up. The bottom two tiers were together and they brought out to the car WITHOUT BEING PUT IN A BOX! How can you expect a cake to travel 4 hours outside a box? You can't. When they placed the cake in the vehicle they bumped it against the seat and messed up some of the frosting, not to mention the top was cracked. The second tier was lopsided and falling over ( not from the drive , we received it that way!) And the bottom of the layers were lifting up. When I got a closer chance to look at the cake it looked poorly made and the frosting look liked it has been done in about 2 seconds. The cake was very expensive and not worth the money we paid for it. With it being a wedding cake we expected the best, but received the worst. The cake was delicious and our guests loved it, but it was lopsided in pictures and several of our guests noticed it, it was tacky. I DO NOT recommend ordering a wedding cake here, especially if it has to travel more than a few minutes!
My experience at Shelbycake was nothing less than the best!!! I’m not the type of person who chooses cake for a desert but her cake is A+! Not only that, but I LOVE how there are options for other kinds of deserts. I tried basically everything in the shop and Personally, my favorites were her ice cream bowls, Oreo truffles, and macaroons! Her ice cream bowls have cake folded into the ice cream and it just the perfect blend! If you are ever passing through, I highly suggest stopping in!
Great to work with made some delicious cakes and cupcakes very reasonably priced.Everything was ready for pickup when we arrived and enjoyed all the personal touches they added! Definitely will use again!!